This Week in Abandoned Railroads: Week of November 20, 2026
I am considering a newsletter approach for This Week in Abandoned Railroads, but for now am continuing to publish it as a blog. Let me know your thoughts!
Notes from the Surface Transportation Board's public record, week of November 20, 2026. The saga of the Shenandoah Line is still at the forefront of Abandoned Railroad news this week.
![]() |
| Bridge at Timberville, VA - Shenandoah Rail Corridor photo. |
The Shenandoah Valley Battlefields Foundation and its railroad subsidiary have filed the application they first signaled in September. It asks the Surface Transportation Board (STB) to make Norfolk Southern sell them the 48.5-mile Shenandoah Line between Front Royal and Broadway, Virginia, for one dollar as a condition of approving the Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern merger. Everything below comes from the Board's public filings. As of November 19, the Board had not ruled on the merits of any of it.
What the applicants are asking for
The responsive application is FD 36873, Sub-No. 11, filed and entered November 18 as doc 312998, 198 pages. The applicants are the foundation and Manassas Gap Railroad LLC, described as its wholly owned subsidiary. They bring it under 49 U.S.C. 11324(c) and 49 CFR 1180 and call it a minor transaction.
The request comes with two prices. First, they ask the Board to condition any merger approval on Norfolk Southern divesting the line to them for one dollar. If the Board refuses, they ask for the regulatory minimum under 49 CFR 1152.27(c)(1)(ii), which they calculate at $2,596,690. That total is 132 short tons of steel per track mile at $345 a ton across 48.5 miles ($2,208,690), plus $8,000 per mile ($388,000). That figure is theirs, not the Board's. If both requests are rejected, they ask for 90 days to negotiate with NS, with the Board setting any terms the two sides can't agree on.
The property is the NS B-Line, MP B 51.0 near Riverton Junction at Front Royal to MP B 99.5 at Broadway, through Warren, Shenandoah and Rockingham counties, with lease and fiber optic rights and connections to both NS and CSX.
Their plans are straightforward, if a bit pie-in-the-sky at points: rehabilitate the line in segments, then contract with a Class III operator to provide common carrier service. They say they hold term sheets from two finalists selected through a request for proposals. Those are in Appendix B, which is confidential, so neither operator is named in the public record. A footnote also asks for "compatible public uses," including excursion service and rail with trail.
On traffic, the two sides disagree sharply. The applicants quote NS's statement that "during the past two years, no local traffic has moved over the Line." They respond that NS turned away requests for service, "including as recently as 2025 and 2026." The exhibits supporting that claim are marked Highly Confidential, so the specifics can't be checked from the public record.
The Board set the clock the same day
Decision No. 47 (document 53319), served November 18, is short and procedural, but it sets the deadlines. November 18 was the deadline for responsive or inconsistent applications set in Decision No. 30. Anyone arguing that the foundation's application is incomplete under 49 CFR Part 1180 has until noon Eastern on November 27, and the applicants may reply by noon Eastern on December 1. Comments on the merits come later, if the Board accepts the application.
For now, the question isn't who should own the line. It's whether this 198-page filing contains everything a responsive application is required to include.
The abandonment case has not moved
None of this has produced a ruling in the abandonment case the application is meant to interrupt. AB-290 (Sub-No. 425X) still shows no decision on the motion to hold the case in abeyance. What the docket did receive this week is its first request for service from a named shipper.
AD Engineering, an HVAC component fabricator, wrote to NS on November 4 and filed the letter with the Board on November 16 (document 312875). It asks for freight service at MP B 87.5, at 377 Industrial Park Road in Mount Jackson, Shenandoah County. The company says it recently bought a 60,000-square-foot building next to the B-Line with its own siding and a rail-ready dock that NS once served. It wants to ship about 3,000 tons of tubing a year, roughly eight boxcars a month. Whether or not one customer makes a traffic base is an open question, and the record doesn't show a response from NS. That being said, I would note that NS has a common carrier responsibility to provide service if abandonment is not consummated, and having service along some or all of the road does not negate the possibility of a rail-with-trail for this corridor.
Two other filings support the foundation. The Virginia Poultry Federation filed a statement of support on November 10. On November 17, SMS Rail Service, a Class III railroad operating in New Jersey, Pennsylvania and New York, filed its own support statement in the abandonment docket (document 312915).
Elsewhere this week: two kinds of condition
November 18 was a busy filing day across the Norfolk Southern-Union Pacific Merger case, and I haven't read most of those filings yet. Based on the docket index alone, Iowa Interstate filed responsive applications in Sub-Nos. 37 through 40 seeking trackage rights over NS and UP in Illinois, Iowa and Nebraska. The Virginia Port Authority filed in Sub-No. 32, and the Chicago South Shore & South Bend in Sub-No. 41. At the main docket level, BNSF and Olin filed protests or opposition statements, the Illinois Commerce Commission asked for merger conditions, and the West Virginia Coal Association and Transportation for America filed comments.
CPKC and Soo Line also filed a responsive application (Sub-No. 49), a 1,055-page public redacted version. Rather than asking for a line, it asks the Board to:
- bar UP and NS from impairing Soo Line's existing trackage rights into Chicago and Detroit
- remove what it calls paper-barrier restrictions on traffic and interchange
- protect its access in and out of Chicago at CP 502, including Gibson Yard on the Indiana Harbor Belt
CPKC opposes the merger and asks for these conditions only if the Board approves it. The contrast is worth noting: the same filing window the Shenandoah foundation used to ask for a 48.5-mile line, a Class I railroad used to protect its access across a much larger network.
What happens next:
Completeness challenges to the foundation's application are due at noon Eastern on November 27, and the applicants' reply is due at noon Eastern on December 1. The abeyance motion in AB-290 has no date attached, and the Board hasn't indicated when it will rule.
Key terms
Responsive application: A filing by a third party in a merger case asking the Board to attach conditions to its approval, such as the sale of a line or new trackage rights.
Minor transaction: The Board's category for transactions it expects to have limited competitive impact, which get a shorter review schedule.
49 CFR 1152.27(c)(1)(ii): The rule the applicants cite for the minimum price in a forced sale, which they calculate from the line's scrap value plus a per-mile allowance.
Offer of Financial Assistance (OFA): A process that lets a buyer or subsidizer step in to keep a line in service instead of letting it be abandoned.
Railbanking: Preserving a corridor for future rail use while a trail runs on it in the meantime.
Sources
Surface Transportation Board public filings, searched and read November 20, 2026. Docket index: STB records search.
- FD 36873 Sub-No. 11, responsive application, doc 312998, filed 11/18/2026: PDF
- FD 36873, Decision No. 47, doc 53319, served 11/18/2026: PDF
- AB-290 Sub-No. 425X, SMS Rail Service support statement, doc 312915, filed 11/17/2026: PDF
- AB-290 Sub-No. 425X, AD Engineering letter, doc 312875, filed 11/16/2026: PDF
- FD 36873 Sub-No. 49, CPKC and Soo Line responsive application, doc 313056, filed 11/18/2026: PDF
![]() |
| High Water. Illinois, ca. 1907. Horace Hull Photograph. |
Thanks as always for reading!


Comments
Post a Comment